The Legacy of Pope Benedict XVI: Reflecting on his new biography

This February will mark nine years since the historic renunciation of Pope Benedict XVI. Joseph Ratzinger would have gone down in history as a great theologian without his rise to the chair of St. Peter, although through his papal ministry he became a teacher of the world. The power of Benedict’s writing speaks for itself, though his life also witnesses to the power of truth and service. Peter Seewald, who edited many interview books with Cardinal Ratzinger, before, during, and after his pontificate, has written a thorough biography in two volumes: “Benedict XVI: A Life” (Bloomsbury Continuum, Vol. 1, 2020; Vol. 2, 2021). With Seewald’s unparalleled access to the pontiff, the strength of his biography comes from bringing Benedict’s personality to the forefront, helping us to get to know the great theologian-pope better, while gaining insight into the providentially guided trajectory of his life.

The first volume traces his early life in the tumult of the interwar period in Germany and the rise of Nazism. I felt much admiration for the pope’s own father, Joseph Sr., who, as a police officer, resisted the rise of the Nazis and kept his family out of danger for as long as possible, even moving to a remote farm. It was precisely the Second World War that deepened young Joseph’s sense of vocation and his recognition of the urgent need for God, as he witnessed the spiritual and material collapse of his own country. As a seminarian, he also discovered the great power of theology, particularly in the thought of St. Augustine, that pointed to how the modern world could recover God. Ratzinger sensed his theological vocation in finding a new voice through which he could make the timeless truths of the faith accessible in a new way.

The second volume begins, however, with upheaval that followed Vatican II, which necessitated Cardinal Ratzinger’s break with the progressive school of theology. He helped to found an alternate movement, the Communion school, which would continue to return to the sources of the tradition while speaking to contemporary concerns. Cardinal Ratzinger, it should be noted, did not suddenly change his thinking; he realized, rather, that many in the Church were too quickly casting aside the Church’s teaching and liturgical tradition and embracing a worldly spirit. His resistance to this self-destruction led to a long campaign of character assassination, seeking to recast the shy and mild-mannered professor as a reactionary grand inquisitor.

After serving tirelessly throughout Pope John Paul II’s pontificate, dealing with issues of Marxism, the relation of the Church to other religions, and the drafting of the Catechism, Pope Benedict XVI was chosen as the most fitting successor to continue the trajectory of the New Evangelization. There is no doubt that Pope Benedict left a great legacy of teaching in his three encyclicals and many speeches throughout the world, although his eight years as pope were also plagued by ongoing and unfounded attacks on his character and scandals such as Vati-Leaks. His time as pope has been overshadowed by his historic decision to resign, facing the weakness of advanced old age, which many saw as changing the way we view papacy.

It is difficult to avoid comparing Seewald’s work to George Weigel’s monumental biography of Pope John Paul II, “Witness to Hope.” Weigel was well positioned to interpret the theological and philosophical thrust of Karol Wojtyła’s life, as well as its intersections with the political and cultural movements of the 20th century. Seewald came to know Pope Benedict well and did succeed in capturing his personality, itself a helpful accomplishment. As a journalist, he gives excessive focus to public opinion, and, although he does address the pope’s major books and speeches, more work needs to be done to capture the depth of his theological vision and spiritual life.  In my own opinion, we will find Pope Benedict XVI’s legacy most fully in his tireless and prophetic witness to the need to put God first in all things, giving him primacy in the liturgy, society, and in our own lives.